Saturday, July 09, 2005

the (real) da vinci code

So I finished the Da Vinci Code yesterday. It was a pretty entertaining book. Not great, but interesting. Assuming they get some decent actors and a good budget, the movie should do pretty well. A friend of mine already lent me a copy of Angels and Demons (the book to which The Da Vinci Code is actually a sequel which deals with the Illuminati and the Vatican).

Anyway, part of the The Da Vinci Code really focuses on a secret stash of documents which establish a radically different alternative understanding of Christian history. I'm not going to spoil the novel by giving away whether the characters find this hidden stash or not. But in the "real world", if you are curious, you might be interested in checking out some of the many resources out there associated with early alternative forms of Christianity.

The most significant alternative form of early Christianity is Gnosticism.

A good resource for looking at many of these alternative texts (Other gospels, the Nag Hammadi texts, the Dead Sea Scrolls, etc.) is the Gnostic Society Library

Another good place to look is the Wesley Center Online's page on Noncanonical Literature or the early Christian writings page

There is a large amount of overlap among these pages but you they each have their differences too.

From a Muslim perspective this literature is especially interesting because it can help fill a particular gap: If Jesus was a Muslim, then where did the original Christians go, and where did the Pauline Christians come from?

By looking at these alternative texts maybe we can come closer to the actual Gospel of Jesus; the Injeel described in the Quran. And by looking at the history of these other groups perhaps we can understand the process by which Christianity went from the original teachings of Christ, to spreading and "mutating" into a larger movement with ALOT of theological diversity, and then changing again into the official religion of the Holy Roman Empire.

For example, some Christian groups had different understandings of the crucifixion and saw Jesus as a human and not as the divine second person of the Trinity.

17 comments:

Rayhana said...

assalaamu'alaykum
i stumbled upon your review of the Da Vinci Code when searching if anyone commented on it from an Islamic point of view.

have u by any chance come across anything else, since reading the book?

personally, i have only just completed reading it, and the point about Jesus (alayhi salam) being a human being has already been mentioned in the Qur'an. however, as there is no mention of mary magdalene, i don't suppose it is that important, as if it was, it would've been mentioned in the Qur'an?

wassalaam :)

Abdul-Halim V. said...

wa alaikum salaam,

To be honest I haven't read anything new. I'm not sure if there are any Islamic texts which say anything about Mary Magdalene.
Without getting into a discussion about whether they are Muslim or not, I know that the Ahmadiyyah believe that somehow Jesus physically survived the crucifixion, revived, and ultimately moved to India and had a wife and children. I don't know if those accounts mention Mary Magdalene as the wife and I don't know if those accounts might be based on hadith (however weak).

So basically... I don't know anything...lol...

Rayhana said...

assalaamu'alaykum

thank you for your response :)

i think i will just stick to what the Qur'an has to say on the matter at hand.

Wallahu alam!

wassalaamu'alaykum

Abdul-Halim V. said...

Yes, wa allahu alim is a good policy.

Anonymous said...

a'kum
i'm almost done reading the book and it really is interesting so far. it's just that i'm still confused whether or not the book is indeed a fiction, because i read from another website claiming that dan brown became a believer after he completed his research. can someone please explain? thank u. :)

Abdul-Halim V. said...

wa alaikum salaam azyyati,

I'm not sure what you mean. The book itself is clearly fiction.

The theories which which the background of the book are debateable. Some people believe them, others clearly don't.

If you want to learn more about those theoreies, I haven't read this book myself, but I would think a really good resource would be Holy Blood, Holy Grail. I think one of the characters in the Da Vinci Code might actually mention this book and the name of a character are actually based on the names of the authors.

Anonymous said...

excuse me for not being clear with the question. what i wanna know is about the truth regarding the priory of sion and the churches going after the sangreal documents. are those things really exist? however no matter what the stories are, al-Quran is what i believe in heart. wassalam

Abdul-Halim V. said...

To be honest, I'm not sure what can be historically verified. I would check out that book, Holy Blood Holy Grail. I think very little is proven. Either way.

Farhad Omar said...

Assalamualaikum

The Da Vinci Code in itself is far reaching towards the process of Al-Qiamah where we will find the world populated only by Muslims. The book does reveal the truth that Isa (Jesus) Alay Salam is only human as all the prophets mentioned in the Holy Quran. Further the Gospels are supposedly to described and narrate the life of the Prophet. In view of this, Prophet Muhammad (SAW) was sent by Him to correct the wrongs that has occurred for more than 600 years.

If you note in the book as well, the paganistic rituals were very much a practice of the Quraish in the early days of the Prophet. Further, the uncovering of the Gospel of Judas only shed more Light to the conditions of that time.

Jesus IS human and if he did marry only He Knows.

Wassalam

Anonymous said...

Assalamu Alaikum,

I just want to say that Islam which defines our actions and belief didnt come until the time of our Beloved Prophet (PBUH). However, all the Prophets (PBU them all) were Muslims as they practiced what Allah wished. Actions that we do today such as sacrificing animals which was practiced by Ibrahim (PBUH) are still done today.

My personal viewpoint is that Jesus (PBUH) did not have any affairs. The Qur'an does not mention this however, so I dont think it is wise to think too much about this matter. We are told that Jesus (PBUH) will return, so logically, is it better to think that Jesus (PBUH) didnt have any relations?

Kashef, UK

Abdul-Halim V. said...

salaams,

in general I primarily think of "Islam" as primarily the path of Muhammad (saaws) but in another sense, the religion of all the prophets. So I would tend not to say that "Islam began with Muhammad" or that "there were no Muslims on the earth" before him.

In terms of the last comment, even the Da Vinci Code aren't saying that Jesus had some kind of illicit affair with Mary Magdalene. They are saying that they actually got married.

Abdul-Halim V. said...

abid, on whether jesus (as) was married or not. I've seen hadith about what you mention before, but it has been a while and i wasn't sure how authentic they were supposed to be. If they are authentic and the meaning was clear, then that would settle things pretty well.

In the Bible there are many different Marys and Mary Magdelene is definitely a very different person from Mary the mother of Jesus.

Also "the Old Testament" isn't the Taurat. The Jewish versions of the Taurat and the Zabur are both a part of the Old Testament.

Anonymous said...

Salaams,

Check out Surah 13, Ayat 38 and see what Allah (SWT) has said about messengers before Muhammad (PBUH).

We did send messengers before thee, and appointed for them wives and children: and it was never the part of a messenger to bring a sign except as Allah permitted (or commanded). For each period is a Book (revealed). Yusuf Ali translation

Abdul-Halim V. said...

yes, wives and children. But it doesn't say when. Some argue that Jesus will have wives and children but as part of the second coming... because it wasn't done the first time around.

Anonymous said...

As usual, the Western film and entertainment industry makes money out of this thing.

Even mobilephones sponsor the Da Vinci code film or novel.

As for us Muslims, dont get distracted too much - we all know about Jesus a.s and his descent to the earth.

What we really be concerned is The Da JJAL CODE which is the Dajjalic system so pervasive in our world today.

There are SYMBOLS, SPIRITS, AND STRATEGY OF THE DAJJAL that we ought to be aware of.

If you have children, will you see him or her to be a Muslim? The Dajjal system wants the young Muslims to grow secular and away from Islam.

The Mukminin fight in the path of Allah, whereas the Kuffar fight in the way of Taghut (anything other than Islam). So fight the party of Satan, for the satanic plot is weak.

Muslimin.org

Anonymous said...

Salaams,

The verbs below are in the past tense when the were presented to Muhammad (PBUH). Meaning these events happened before Muhammad's time.

13:38: We did send messengers before thee, and appointed for them wives and children: and it was never the part of a messenger to bring a sign except as Allah permitted (or commanded). For each period is a Book (revealed). Yusuf Ali translation

Anonymous said...

A'Alaykum

I kind of stumbled on this search right now. I am not even really sure about what Planet Grenada is all about(say what! is right). However I've read Da Vinci about a year back and just recently saw the movie. Actually, i pondered many many days about these same questions finally leading to the one and only conclusion that my 9 year old sister put so eloquently, "Who cares?? what matters is whats important!" The Qu'ran is the truth, untainted, whole. What matters are the teachings of Islam and our Prophet(pbuh).As a child I remember getting to fierce debates with my christian friends about Jesus (AS) being the son of god. The truth finds its way out.I can only hope that more people turn to Islam and see the light it posseses. Boy, do i feel like saying to them, "see i told you so."

oh yes one more thing. Does anyone know about Prophet Yahya(as)and his connection to Prophet Isa(as)? (I know the christian story unfortuantely,i don't think its quite reliable)